Tweeting Christine Tietz's "Karl Barth: A Life in Conflict"
It is very good.
In fact, reading it prompted me to update my guide to reading Barth (which I origianlly wrote in 2007 and haven't updated since ~2013) in order to include it: So, You Want To Read Karl Barth?.
Very early in the process of reading Tietz's book I realized that I would want to share about the volume. So I decided to tweet my way through it. And below I have pulled together all those tweets for folks who may have seen one or two and wondered about the rest, folks who might be interested but aren't on Twitter, etc. Enjoy reading, and then go but the book!
Chapter 2 tweet for Tietz's #KarlBarth biography:
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 7, 2022
I love and am not surprised by this insight into Barth as a student:
"In general Barth was a neat student. He had his lecture notes and excerpts of biblical texts and theological works bound carefully and numbered them." (24)
For example, noting that Barth "had the courage" to ask his #confirmation students for feedback on his course of instruction, Tietz writes:
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 8, 2022
"Unfortunately their answers have not been preserved" (51).#LMFAO (2/2)
...Barth wrote a private letter to the father in the midst of public disagreement with the son, trying to maintain "the good relationship between the manufacturer's family and the parsonage" (64).
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 9, 2022
Good for Karl showing some political subtlety! 😂
Here's a freebie in my tweeting of Tietz's #KarlBarth bio.
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 9, 2022
Her discussion in chapter 4 (on p. 69) of Barth's reaction to German theology and World War 1 would benefit from @dwcongdon 's scholarship on the subject. https://t.co/C4LNYfqmzg
Chapter 6 tweet for Tietz's #KarlBarth bio:
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 10, 2022
I knew that Barth and Erik Peterson knew each other in Göttingen. I did *not* know that "Barth sat in on Peterson's lectures on Thomas #Aquinas in the 1923/24 winter semester" (112) - an interesting footnote to their later exchange.
Also, I have a podcast series going on #KarlBarth's Göttingen #dogmatics lectures.
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 10, 2022
Here's the link to the intro installment: https://t.co/mSKefXAZTi https://t.co/kQI3CGHTdL
Chapter 8 tweet for Tietz's #KarlBarth bio:
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 11, 2022
Interesting facts:
- Barth too horseback riding lessons while in Munster, which made him late to faculty meetings and resulted in a serious injury (167-68).
- Nelly called him on his bullsh^t when he was hassling other people (157)
Tietz handles things well, putting together the play-by-play as best she can based on surviving evidence without engaging in either apologetics or denunciations. There's a lot of pathos between the lines.
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 11, 2022
I heard Tietz lecture on the subject at AAR a few years back, ... (2/4)
In any case, the chapter ends with the fraught balancing act established in the early 1930s. It will be interesting to see how Tietz (hopefully) interweaves the subject throughout the rest of the volume. (4/4)
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) September 11, 2022
Chapter 10 tweets for Tietz's #KarlBarth bio:
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) October 1, 2022
The highlights of this chapter for me were (1) insight into his relationship with his brothers and sister, and their spouses & significant others; (2) the blow-by-blow account of his battled with Swiss censors during the war.
Chapter 11 tweets for Tietz's #KarlBarth bio:
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) October 1, 2022
This chapter covers an extensive time period (1945-62) but skips thematically through the material and enlivens it with telling detail. Rearmament. East/West conflict. Ecumenism. Vacation plans. Colleagues. Students. Etc.
Second, "learn to read!" as the motto for #KarlBarth's seminars (as distinct from his lectures).
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) October 1, 2022
For some time I have used the motto of "think interesting thoughts!" in my #teaching. But I'm going to steal Barth's sentiment to pair with it from now on.
😂 Also, for anyone following along, I just noticed that my chapter numbering has been off.
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) October 1, 2022
It looks like I did chapter 9 twice; the second instance should have been chapter 10.
So the one quoted here should have been chapter 12.
Best laid plans... https://t.co/oC66aciRTW
Chapter 13 (numbering corrected) tweets for Tietz's #KarlBarth bio:
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) October 1, 2022
This was all about #ChurchDogmstics. I don't think I've ever read such a succinct and compelling summary of CD's volumes and major themes. Very well done. I cannot recommend it highly enough as an intro to KB.
...driving one forward suddenly isn't there? Or the people who've always supported you can't do it anymore? Or you look up and realize that you had t made as much of a difference, or the kind of difference, that you thought?
— W. Travis McMaken (@WTravisMcMaken) October 1, 2022
"Lord, receive me, a poor sinner, with mercy!"
FIN
==================================
Follow @WTravisMcMaken
Subscribe to Die Evangelischen Theologen
Comments